Three Capitals for Two States

About the Book

This study argues that there are historical reasons to focus on Jerusalem first and to use an international Holy Basin methodology to bring Israel and the Palestinian National Authority together toward a workable compromise. This analysis identifies the strategic compromises required to create two distinct capital zones that grants sovereignty and legitimacy over respective capitals for the state of Israel and a future state of Palestine. In terms of religion and national identity, Jerusalem is a central factor for both Israelis and Palestinians, to the people of three world religions, and to the international community. The critical factors to achieve compromise are sovereignty over their respective capitals combined with international recognition and possible international control over remaining contested holy places. Resolving the city’s role as a national capital for two states can lead to resolving other critical Arab-Israeli issues. The international community has perpetuated the conflict by withholding Jerusalem sovereignty from Israel and the Arab population. When Britain ended their Palestine mandate in 1948, the UN failed to deliberately enforce their vision of a separate Jerusalem entity, or corpus separatum. The UN continued to withhold sovereignty while the city was divided for nineteen years between Jordan and Israel and when the city was reunited in 1967. The lack of an international mandate for sixty-four years while fighting for utopian concepts has perpetuated the conflict by delaying the self-determination of the Palestinian population and withholding sovereignty over Israel’s declared capital. Peace negotiations must recognize and incorporate the interests of both sides, but until each side is ready to strictly divide the Old City, an international Holy Basin zone has the potential to create a new reality while moving incrementally from confrontation to cooperation.

About the Author

Carl Dick is a graduate of the US ArmySchoolofAdvancedMilitary Studies, Missouri University of Science and Technology, and Arizona State University in Civil/ Environmental Engineering. He has served as an enlisted combat engineer, a forward observer in the Arizona National Guard, and currently serves as an engineer offi cer with posts in the U.S., Korea, Germany, Iraq, and Afghanistan. He had the opportunity to work with leaders of the Al Anbar Awakening and built police stations in Ramadi to protect the population. Major Carl Dick is currently a future operations planner in Headquarters, International Security Assistance Force (ISAF), Afghanistan.